It was bound to happen. Day Five at the MidAtlantic has a history of dramatic finishes and 2022 would be no different. Many a crewmember has spent the night before the final day of the tournament tossing and turning as they nervously await the end of the final day of fishing. Way back in 1997 the phrase “Moving Day” was first used for Day Five at this event because of the big changes that occur to the leaderboard. Fortunes have been made and dashed over the years and 2022 would be no different as Day Five saw several major changes and a new tournament record set as well! The final day of fishing saw the largest fleet of the week head offshore as 160 boats had Day Five of the tournament left to fish and hopefully get a piece of the tournament’s $5.23 million purse.
Going into the final day of fishing Michael Jordan’s Jupiter, Florida-based Catch 23 sat atop the leaderboard in the white marlin category with his 73-pounder followed by Vero Beach, Florida’s Matthew Weber aboard his Max Bet with a 65 pounder. The tournament fleet, including Jordan and Weber, both veterans of this event, knew those two fish were beatable and although the numbers of white marlin caught grew as the week wore on, finding one to meet the 69-inch, 65-pound minimum was proving to be difficult. As the weigh-in session got underway word began to leak out of boated white marlin of significant length that could potentially shake up the leaderboard. The sun was beginning to set as Captain Steve Castellini backed the Kaarmaa of Millstone, New Jersey’s Anthony Alves to the scale at Canyon Club Resort Marina in Cape May with a white marlin to weigh for Alves who was also the angler. As the billfish was hoisted from the boat it was clear this fish was going to challenge the top two fish on the board. After taking the measurement the marlin was hoisted to the scale and Weighmaster Chris Booth confirmed the weight of 75 pounds to put Kaarmaa in the lead of the category. However, word began to spread of another white marlin coming to Cape May and just 30 minutes later Captain Michael Pintozzi of Langhorne, Pennsylvania pulled up to the scale with his Random Chaos to weigh a white marlin for angler Tom Jarvis. As the crowd of tournament participants looked on the billfish was placed on the scale and the weight of 66 pounds was announced to put Random Chaos in third place. In the end Kaarmaa’s 75-pounder took the top spot in the category and won $871,404. Catch 23’s 73-pounder caught on Day Three was second and received $693,615 while Random Chaos held on to third place and won $192,165.
The blue marlin category was hotly contested all week long and the 56 blues caught is the second highest in the tournament’s tenure topped only by the 68 blues caught in 2019. As has been the case in several Day Five’s at the MidAtlantic over the years, darkness would cover Canyon Club Resort Marina as a blue marlin would be weighed and this year it would be the final fish weighed in the tournament. The Avalon, New Jersey-based Low Profile of Captain Joe Trainor had a blue marlin on the deck that taped out at 122¾” which angler Ken Wibble battled for well over three hours before being boated. As the huge billfish was hoisted to the scale and positioned you could hear a pin drop and moments later the weight of 657 pounds was announced by Weighmaster Chris Booth. Low Profile took home $576,209 for the heaviest blue marlin while Robert Boyce of Key Largo, Florida finished in second place aboard his Lucky 7 and won $168,625 for his 619-pounder caught on Day Four. Christopher Kinsley of Seven Valleys, Pennsylvania aboard his Kilo Charlie took third place and received $580,119 for his 607-pounder caught on Day Three. Worthy of note for the second consecutive year the top three blue marlin in the tournament were all over 600 pounds.
The tuna category was another competitive category as no less than 86 of that species were weighed. Although yellowfins were plentiful, big eyes were scarce and only three were weighed during the week and none of the tuna weighed on Day Five made a run at the leaders. Art Boykin of Berlin, Maryland aboard his Lucky Duck took the top prize of $290,050 in the category with a big eye of 210 pounds caught on Day Four. For the second consecutive year a boat would win two places in the category and this year it was Summit, New Jersey’s Bob Hugin aboard his The Right Place who took second and third place with big eyes of 193 and 152 pounds caught on Day One and won a total of $793,014 for both places.
The wahoo division saw a complete overhaul of the category on Day Five and the top prize of $65,729 went to Plantation, Florida’s Charles Phelan aboard his Special Situation for a tournament record 104-pounder which breaks the previous tournament record of 97 pounds set by Bill Gallo aboard his Joanna back in 2009. Second place went to Keith Boyd of Ivyland, Pennsylvania aboard his Craftsmanship with a 72-pounder worth $57,528. Third place and $14,570 goes to Mike Penza of North Palm Beach, Florida aboard his Oil Slick for a 46-pounder.
The dolphin category saw Fort Pierce, Florida’s Joseph Valentine aboard his Valentine win $78,231 for a 43- pounder caught on Day Four. Billy Wrede of Randolph, New Jersey aboard Lovin’ Life finished second with a 39- pounder and won $34,874, also caught on Day Four. Donnie White of Pottstown, Pennsylvania aboard his Sea Wolf finished in third place with a 33-pound dolphin weighed on Day Five and won $24,722.
Some of the boats with notable billfish releases on Day Five include Ed Dunn’s D.A. Sea with six white marlin and one blue marlin released. Peter Lorris’ Hydrosphere released three white marlin and a blue marlin. Michael Pintozzi’s Random Chaos and Joe Bernert’s Quick Raise each released a blue marlin. Pat Healey’s Viking 80 released five white marlin while Rob Gothier’s Bar South, Frank Goodhart’s Brenda Lou and Dave Smith’s Code Blu each released four white marlin. Matthew Weber’s Max Bet and Newt Cagle’s Hatterascal each released three white marlin.
Cash Prize Winners
Note that cash payouts vary by the level of calcuttas a participant enters.
Heaviest White Marlin – 75 lbs. – Kaarmaa – Anthony Alves – Millstone, NJ – $871,404
2nd Heaviest White Marlin – 73 lbs. – Catch 23 – Michael Jordan – Jupiter, FL – $658,045
3rd Heaviest White Marlin – 66 lbs. – Random Chaos – Michael Pintozzi – Langhorne, PA – $95,364
Heaviest Blue Marlin – 657 lbs. – Low Profile – Joe Trainor – Avalon, NJ – $576,209
2nd Heaviest Blue Marlin – 619 lbs. – Lucky 7 – Robert Boyce – Key Largo, FL – $161,011
3rd Heaviest Blue Marlin – 607 lbs. – Kilo Charlie – Christopher Kinsley – Seven Valleys, PA – $580,119
Heaviest Tuna – 210 lbs. – Lucky Duck – Art Boykin – Berlin, MD – $290,050
2nd Heaviest Tuna – 193 lbs. – The Right Place – Bob Hugin – Summit, NJ – $604,376
3rd Heaviest Tuna – 152 lbs. – The Right Place – Bob Hugin – Summit, NJ – $188,638
*Heaviest Wahoo – 104 lbs. – Special Situation – Charles Phelan – Plantation, FL – $65,729
2nd Heaviest Wahoo – 72 lbs. – Craftsmanship – Keith Boyd – Ivyland, PA – $57,528
3rd Heaviest Wahoo – 46 lbs. – Oil Slick – Michael Penza – North Palm Beach, FL – $14,570
*New tournament record.
Heaviest Dolphin – 43 lbs. – Valentine – Michael Penza – North Palm Beach, FL – $78,231
2nd Heaviest Dolphin – 39 lbs. – Lovin’ Life – Billy Wrede – Randolph, NJ – $34,874
3rd Heaviest Dolphin – 33 lbs. – Sea Wolf – Donnie White – Pottstown, PA – $24,722
Huk Billfish Points Calcutta – Cape May
Most Points – 750 – Viking 80 – Pat Healey – New Gretna, NJ – $12,690
2nd Most Points – 604.75 – Lucky 7 – Robert Boyce – Key Largo, FL – $7,614
3rd Most Points – 600 – Outrage – John Dougherty – Villanova, PA – $5,076
Atlantic Tackle Billfish Points Calcutta – Ocean City
Most Points – 1,040 – Max Bet – Matthew Weber – Vero Beach, FL – $23,790
2nd Most Points – 868 – Bar South – Rob Gothier, Jr. – York, PA – $14,382
3rd Most Points – 825 – Reel Joy – John Gudelsky – Singer Island, FL – $9,588
The following received calcutta winnings for various positions on the leaderboard during the tournament:
65 lbs. – RoShamBo – Nick Shriver – Leonardtown, MD – $276,021
65 lbs. – Max Bet – Matthew Weber – Vero Beach, FL – $39,668
539 lbs. – No Quarter – Michael Peet – New Castle, DE – $47,752
528 lbs. – Oil Slick – Michael Penza – North Palm Beach, FL – $11,468
494 lbs. – D.A. Sea – Edward Dunn – Grasonville, MD – $267,937
490 lbs. – Random Chaos – Michael Pintozzi – Langhorne, PA – $32,373
469 lbs. – Three’s Enough – Justin Branning – Manasquan, NJ – $24,665
461 lbs. – Endorphin – Jere Murdoch – Howell, NJ – $29,365
414 lbs. – The Zipper – Eddie Zajdel – Ocean City, MD – $24,402
88 lbs. – Random Chaos – Michael Pintozzi – Langhorne, PA – $32,054
84 lbs. – Catch 23 – Michael Jordan – Jupiter, FL – $32,336
82 lbs. – Double R – Rob Rowe – Jacksonville, FL – $3,233
82 lbs. – No Quarter – Michael Peet – New Castle, DE – $3,233
82 lbs. – C Student – Keely Megarity – Houston, TX – $3,233
82 lbs. – Catch 23 – Michael Jordan – Jupiter, FL – $3,233
82 lbs. – C Student – Keely Megarity – Houston, TX – $3,233
82 lbs. – Random Chaos – Michael Pintozzi – Langhorne, PA – $32,373
82 lbs. – Endorphin – Jere Murdoch – Howell, NJ – $8,272
82 lbs. – Tara Jessica – Gregory Wendell – Owings Mills, MD – $4,136
Point Winners (Trophies)
Most Points Overall – 1,040 – Max Bet – Matthew Weber – Vero Beach, FL
Most Points White Marlin – 1,040 – Max Bet – Matthew Weber – Vero Beach, FL
2nd Most Points White Marlin – 750- Bar South – Rob Gothier, Jr. – York, PA
3rd Most Points White Marlin – 750 – Viking 80 – Pat Healey – New Gretna, NJ
Most Points Blue Marlin – 450 – Quick Raise – Joe Bernert – Hatboro, PA
2nd Most Points Blue Marlin – 304.75 – Lucky 7 – Robert Boyce – Key Largo, F
3rd Most Points Blue Marlin – 300 – Reel Joy – John Gudelsky – Singer Island, FL
Most Points Tuna – 174.5 – Double R – Rob Rowe – Jacksonville, FL
2nd Most Points Tuna – 172.5 – The Right Place – Bob Hugin – Summit, NJ
3rd Most Points Tuna – 168.5 – Reel Chaos – Donna Matarese – Pennsville, NJ
White Marlin Released – 320
White Marlin Weighed – 14
Blue Marlin Released – 41
Blue Marlin Weighed – 15
Tuna Weighed – 86
Dolphin Weighed – 18
Wahoo Weighed – 9
Rather than focus on awarding a single large payout for one winning fish, the MidAtlantic tournament prize structure is designed to award large payouts to multiple winners and this year was no different. Four winners received checks of $576 thousand or more while five more received checks of $168 thousand or more. An additional five winners received checks of $57 thousand or more.
For further information contact Tournament Director Aaron Hoffman at 609-884-0177 or visit the tournament’s web site at www.themidatlantic.com where you’ll find all the facts, figures and information about this year’s event including a complete rundown of calcutta payouts, rules, points, and an event schedule. On social media follow the MidAtlantic on Facebook at The MidAtlantic Tournament; on Twitter @midatl and on Instagram @themidatlantictournament.